Founder of the Vanguard Group, Jack Bogle, is not a fan of investing abroad.
The creator of indexed mutual funds thinks that investing outside of the US is too risky and American investors should keep their money at home.
He has said that numerous times, but in an interview with Bloomberg View’s Barry Ritholtz, Bogle has something more to say – US investors already have money invested overseas even if they don’t know it!
He said, “US companies get half of their revenues… and half of their earnings from outside the US”.
“You have an international portfolio, why do you want a larger one?”
Bogle’s argument is that most companies already have sales in international markets, so by investing directly in foreign stocks investors are also exposing themselves to the macroeconomic conditions of those nations. In essence, you’re not diversifying your risks away from the US economy but adding another risk to your portfolio.
As an example, Bogle points to the 3 largest holdings in international index funds.
Bogle said, “So if people knew they were putting 45% of their so-called international, non-US, money in Great Britain, France and Japan – I mean every one of those three countries has real problems”.
He continued, “The French don’t work very hard, The Japanese have a structured and deeply aging economy overburdened by future retirement claims… Britain doesn’t know what’s going to happen if they do the exit from the European community, nor do they know what’s going to happen if they stay in.”
Bogle also didn’t like the idea of equally weighting the exposure of an international portfolio to avoid this pitfall as it would include other unstable names.
“I don’t like the idea [of equal weighted foreign exposure] because you would have as much in, I don’t know, Honduras as you do in Great Britain,” said Bogle. “It wouldn’t make any sense.”
He also noted that a US-only portfolio has performed significantly well compared with a non-US portfolio, 22 years since his call against foreign investment in his book “Bogle on Mutual Funds”.
He did acknowledge that foreign investments’ underperformance against the US is unlikely to be as great as it has been, but there is no reason to think non-US markets will markedly outperform the US even if this spread narrows.
Bogle said, “I don’t think they will reverse, but I don’t think that spread is a durable spread”.
“And the reason I don’t think it will reverse is that we have this fabulous economy here. I mean yes it has problems, but probably less problems than any country in the world.”